Anindianmuslim.com: Blog against fundamentalism. We stand for communal harmony, composite culture and humanism. Leading Indian Muslim Voice on internet since mid-2005. Now in its 10th year. More than a MILLION HITS by 2012. For ad related queries, write to indscribe@anindianmuslim.com

Monday, August 31, 2009

Should the Waqf Boards be disbanded in India?


It is true that the Waqf properties in India are so huge that they are enough to finance the educational and social needs of Muslims, however, gross corruption in most of the Waqf Boards and the greed of officials has wrecked the system.

For over a millennium, Muslims in India have been setting aside property [or part of property] and pledging it, in the name of God, for charitable works. The purpose was that the earnings would go to the upkeep of orphans, widows and for other social causes.

Even in rural areas there are waqf properties that can fetch earnings to the tune of crores. But this money that should go in establishment of orphanages, opening charitable hospitals, schools, colleges, disbursing pensions to destitutes and scholarships to poor students, is mostly gobbled by the corrupt bureaucracy.

How the earnings from Waqf properties is siphoned off? My personal experience. I would cite just a few examples:

1. Commercial establishments and shops on Waqf properties [like the shops around mosques or grave yards] are let out to relatives on nominal rent, sometimes as low as Rs 50 or 100. That's because the corrupt waqf officials take bribes to let out shops.

2. The corrupt 'mutawallis' [caretakers] and those in district waqf committees, even sell the Waqf land or 'allow encroachment', as they are in cahoots with encroachers. Often the caretaker himself grabs the land.

3. The legal cells don't fight cases. Lawyers of Waqf Boards are often 'bought' by the other party that has encroached a property and sold it after constructing a multi-storey complex on it.

4. Political-bureaucratic-land mafia nexus is always eyeing the Waqf land. Though a waqf property can not be sold or it's use changed till eternity, the exact opposite happens, because lands are mostly in prime locations. They are given on lease in lieu of money that goes in the pockets of officials. If cases go to courts, the files disappear and lawyers often don't put up defence.

5. In states where the upright officials want to pursue cases, the district administration doesn't take interest, citing that removal of encroachments may lead to law-and-order issue. The collectors, DMs, ADMs and tehsildars aren't interested enough to take the help of police and municipal corporation, to execute the anti-encroahment drive.

The earning from Waqf properties could be to the tune of tens of crores from any of the big states in India, but mostly the boards are in loss. Some of the reasons have been mentioned above, however, I will give more examples.

In case of an old mosque, there are nearly 100 shops on the ground floor, basement and on the land around the mosque. However, the rents were last fixed in pre-independence era and continue to be Rs 5-Rs 18.

The traders who earn lakhs a day because they sit on the most precious property in a town, won't pay more rent as the Board doesn't want it either. The officials go routinely every year and 'settle' the matter 'unofficially'.

The property of Dargah Baba Kapur on the border of Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh is unimaginable. The waqf land is spread to over 500 villages. But not a penny reaches the Board. All money goes to a pre-independence era department and the Board never showed inclination to fight the case or get the revenue that could be spent on charitable works.

Wrecking the Waqf

Unfortunately, most of the corrupt officials in the Waqf Boards are Muslim. They understand the religious and social implications of the corruption but stilly they many not just change the intent of the 'waaqif' [the person who had endowed the property] but also sell it illegally.

For example, if a widow dies, and before his death she had pledged that her land should be deemed Waqf property, and a girls' school ought to be founded on it, it is not possible to change the intent.

But it is routine to find the land leased to a builder or shops constructed over it. What a shame! Blaming the government is wrong, as the levels of corruption and immorality among society is responsible for wrecking the Nizam-e-Awqaf [Auqaaf].

The apathy of Muslims is astonishing to say the least. Recently, the Deputy Chairperson of Rajya Sabha, K Rahman Khan, lamented that Waqf Boards aren't doing their work honestly, else Rs, 10,000 crore could be obtained each year just from rents.

In fact, this amount is also an underestimate. The truth is that the prime property of Waqfs [like the land in Mumbai where Mukesh Ambani's colossal building came up] is worth billions in each state, but is getting encroached, sold and wasted by the day. [See link to CNN-IBN story]

It is in context of this monumental corruption that Firoz Bakht Ahmad recently wrote in Roznama Rashtriya Sahara, that the Boards should be dissolved. He gave example that how the donations at the dargah of Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti is running the households of 5,000 khawaja-zaadgans.

Frankly, Firoz Bakht Ahmad has written what most of us feel but it's also impractical. Do we have an alternative model? There are Waqf Boards in a couple of states that are really doing well.

Successful Waqf Boards in Haryana, Andhra Pradesh

In Andhra Pradesh, even on small plots of land, ATMs and similar establishments were opened, and this brings revenue to Board that is spent on charity and education. In a small state like Haryana, the Board has done wonders and it is running engineering college and other institutions.

Sadly, in large states like UP,Bihar,Maharashtra,West Bengal and the Delhi-Punjab area that has huge waqf land, corruption on hitherto unimaginable proportions, has reduced the Waqf Boards to a status where they are permanently in debt and eternally crisis-ridden.
[Photo courtesy Gauravcreations.com at Panaramio]

9 comments:

mummyjaan said...

That was a dismal read, until I came to the last paragraph, where you mentioned that there *are* successful waqf boards (Haryana and AP) who have utilized the money and resources in useful ways.

Proabably there is more to this issue than just 'apathy' as you say. There is also ignorance; I have only the haziest idea of what Waqf boards do and it's not hard to imagine that many laypeople might also not know.

Perhaps a demand for greater accountability might be the answer rather than disbanding the boards.

Mateen said...

It is very very disappointing that having thousands of crores of waqf properties we Muslims cannot able to uplift ourselves economically and educationally. Waqf Properties given Rent like shops on Rs. 30,50 must be increase to 10 folds.

Who cares? said...

A good "self-introspection", if I can use that phrase..

At least for once..... ... the Muslims of Inida not blaming the Hindus or the BJP for their plight!!

Yayaver said...

It may not be related to your posted material about Waqf board but muttawa is the diary of a Saudi man who describes the life back at Saudi Arabia through 2 years span of blogging. I am a new reader of your blog from few months. Just passing this link for the sake of providing one more pov of life and religious practice of Islam.

Anonymous said...

Every leader whether hindu or muslims is for sale to rich. What is required is the people must try to help each other and never build pyramid structure.

Pyramid structure become more corrupt and donot serve the purpose.

indscribe said...

@ mummyjaan: You are right that people are not much aware. The lack of interest among Muslims and relatively low social activism among the community, is responsible for the situation. There are huge chunks of land in every city and often there are govt offices and private buildings constructed on them but waqf boads take no more than a few hundred or thousands in rent, sometimes no rent at all.

@ Mateen: Ya, the land which Waqf Boards have, is enough to take care of the education and health needs of the Muslims. But apathy and mindboggling corruption is responsile for the mess.

Thanks Yayaver, Anon. Who cares for your comments.

Anonymous said...

I have been looking at this site and find it to be really helpful. I would really appreciate any assistance.

Anonymous said...

I totally support that! Continue that way!

Anonymous said...

Sup im fresh on here, I hit upon this board I have found It positively accessible and it has helped me out a lot. I hope to contribute and aid other people like it has helped me.

Cheers, Catch You Later.