Search This Website


Friday, July 10, 2009

India's own Guantanamo Bays: The Week's story on Secret torture chambers

A 14-year-old boy, Irfan, was crossing the road near his house in Delhi when a Tavera car screeched to a halt near him, he was bundled into the car and pinned down under the heavy feet with pistol kept to his head.

The mother kept searching for the boy. Had it not the car's numberplate and the judiciary's help, the boy may not have been tracked and released in ten days, from a secret Abu Gharaib-like torture cell in faraway Gujarat where he underwent such torture which even the adults can't even dream to endure.

This explosive story by news magazine 'The Week' has caused ripples in administrative circles. After a long time, a news magazine has done such an investigative story that brings to light something which was either not known or just talked about in whispers.

The magazine's journalist has unearthed and located these secret detention camps a la Guantanamo Bay, which are present in several Indian cities. The Week's managing editor Philip Mathew has written a special full page introduction for the story and the purpose of this extraordinary revelation. He writes:

..The muffled cry will never reach you. Nor the snap of bone. It is a strange silence, as if tranquilised by terror....the cover story is vastly different from Hitlerian terror, what is common though is the sadistic streak that strips a human of his dignity and sometimes his life...

The Week's cover story on secret torture champers comes at a time when mature democracies are pausing to listen to their conscience....many innocents suffer grievously as they were picked up on mere suspicion and had no access to legal help, nor their families know where they had been taken...

The extensive groundwork and the interviews by The Week's senior correspondent Syed Nazakat are a revelation. Yes, terrorists need to be treated differently. But does the organised might of the state need to torture 14-year-old innocent minor by abducting them and keeping them in soundproof cells that don't have windows and where new definitions of torture are scripted every minute?

Many are traumatised for their life and others die in these chambers without anybody's knowledge. Former DGP and Intelligence Bureau (IB) officer, Dr KS Subramanian's interview is also an eye-opener. He doesn't deny about such practices and says, "...in terrorist-related cases, the police may feel incentive to describe people as terrorists and kill them for professional reasons and career advancement.'

He mentions how farmers were killed in the name of Naxalites. The exhaustive report also tells about the exact location of these terror cells in Kolkata, Palanpur (Gujarat), Delhi, Mumbai and Guwahati--often in houses faraway from police stations.

The importance of the story lies in the fact that often journalists working on a particular beat get sympathetic and close to the system, rather than the citizens. In turn, they turn their back on such grave abuse of human rights. However, the issue is that we always feel it is 'the other' who suffers, not us and we forget.

When women get gang raped in custody, many feel that such incidents keep happening Dalits and Tribals or perhaps to that particular class of 'poor'. When innocents get killed in encounters, we remain indifferent. And in process cede our rights and liberties.

The use of drugs through injections, water boardings, attaching electrodes on genitals and other techniques of torture (as described by the magazine) are not something which any civilised state should allow on innocent citizens.

As the Week's editor writes, "...Irfan is not just Tasleema's 14 year old son. He is an Indian citizen with rights, just like your son and mine..... ". Read the story. Link to the editor's introduction and the story 'India's secret torture chambers'. It's chilling and shocking to say the least. Congratulations to the writer and the magazine for their courage.


Amitabh said...

Well, I know it’s sad that these cells exist but the question is “Do they (IB, RAW etc...) have any choices?” What I mean to say here is these cells are now become relevant to check terrorism. You can’t expect a terrorists confess his wrong doing simply. You do need to do something extra to get the information out. Even a ten year old kid will refuse at first place if you ask simply. Sometimes forces are required. But yes I would like to request these men to release the innocent people ASAP after finding their innocence.

priyanka said...

Contratulations to the whole "The Week" team and to the writer of this post as well (for bringing the issue in front of all those who may have not gone through that magzine).
Fine, now points i want to make about this post:
A)I love print even more than before.Good magzines give you the oppurtunity to investigate and write complex indepth stories.(In contrast to ultra young n chirpy electronic as well as print youth who cannot construct any thing more complex than a 300 word flat easy event report). Children like me feel happy to read about such concrete stories . ATleast i can console myself and motivate myself and say - "Journalism is alive" and i didnt took a wrong step when i stepped into journalism.

B) We all should use net as a medium to spread the populatrity of such stories ( And the likes of stories published in the Hindu, Indian Express, frontline, HT etc). We all should praise such work and respect it and should condem the obselete reporting (if u can call it reporting) done by electronic media.

The journalism faternity should respect people who have brains, who work hard and do serious work.

The parameter should not be: - Who is making more money,who sits with corporate or political leaders,is young, drives esteem,drinks vodka and smokes filtered cigarettes!!!.

It should be all about work. Serious work. Thats all which matters.

Vani said...

Indian police is the most corrupt and anti-people force in India. They salute Salem and Dawood but will keep innocent 10, 12 year old in such cells so that they really come out becoming anti-nationals if they are not.

Even a man of steel will break down in the lockups of police that are full of stench and smell of urine and excreta.

All forms of torture takes place there. But the secret chambers highlighted by week are used only for such activities that don't help the cause of society.

They only create more disgruntled souls. They are not just unethical and unlawful but are also used for putting such people that can help them in extortion or settling illegal deals of crores like between squablling businessmen or traders in illegal activity.